Correlation or Causation? Interceptions and the Playoffs.
SI.com recently ran an article about the ‘interception ladder’. It looked back at playoff games since 1970, and found an interesting statistic. With each interception a team throws (accidentally throwing to the guys in the wrong jersey) the chance that the team won dropped.
Correlation or Causation? Interceptions and the Playoffs
Now, this is a classic case of confusing correlation with causation. If this data truly was a cause and effect relationship, meaning interceptions caused losses, fixing the problem would be simple, and I could one of the best NFL coaches of all time. In fact, you’d never even need to practice for that gameplan.
If you never threw the ball, you could win nearly four out of five times.
Now, anyone who knows much about football will tell you that you can’t win games like that. What that means is that the interception stat is correlated to winning, but may not necessarily cause winning. For example, a better team will often force the other team into mistakes-the interceptions are the effect of the disparity in skill. Or a team that is losing will make riskier throws to try to score quickly.
The Lean lesson is to read into the data and look for the real cause and effect relationships. Remember: Correlation doesn’t necessarily mean causation.
Request from readers: I’m going to put together a football and Lean page. I’ve used it as a backdrop for making Lean points a few times. I’ve noticed a few other Lean bloggers doing the same recently, such as Mark Graban’s post on value-added time in a football game. If you know of any other Lean posts with (American) football as the backdrop, please let me know in the comments section below. Thanks!
Share Your Thoughts |2 comments|
© 2009-2010 by Velaction Continuous Improvement, LLC. All rights reserved.
Other Information You May Be Interested In...
- Correlation Correlation is a statistical term that describes the relationship between two different, measurable factors. The relationship may be positive (same...
- Inspection and Quality. How the NFL Can Teach You About Lean. So, it is a Sunday morning, and the outlook for today is bleak. You see, it is the bye week...
- Cause and Effect (Fishbone) Diagram (+ VIDEO) A cause and effect (fishbone) diagram is a structured, graphical representation of the possible causes to a given effect (cause...
- Cause and Effect Diagram PowerPoint Lean Training The cause and effect diagram (also known as the Ishikawa diagram or the fishbone diagram) provides teams with a way...
- Randomness and Lean and Perfect Games One of the rarest feats in sports is the perfect game. For those non-sports fans among you who don’t know...
User Info
Login
Connections
FREE Lean Information!
| Download FREE Lean Training Now! |
 |
R 38 page tutorial on Pareto charts R Lean Audio training on Standard Work (14 min), Takt Time (14 min), 5 Whys (7 min) R Maximize Your Lean Success monthly newsletter |
We promise never to sell, rent, trade, or share your email with any other organization! |
Regarding your American Football backdrop question, I just wrote an article for my monthly newsletter titled Offense or Defense. You can access it at the following link http://www.leanenterpriseguide.com/tsg_web_site_009.htm
Enjoy.
[...] Correlation or Causation? Interceptions and the Playoffs by Jeff Hajek – “this is a classic case of confusing correlation with causation. If this data truly was a cause and effect relationship, meaning interceptions caused losses, fixing the problem would be simple… If you never threw the ball, you could win nearly four out of five times.” [...]